|
APATHY IS THE ENEMY The
Sunday Times, October 2004
The sight of Prince Harry,
previously dubbed the Playboy Prince, cuddling an African
baby with Aids could
not have come at a better moment in a week in which a survey
of teenagers told us that the number of depressed teenagers
has doubled since … As someone who was a very depressed
teenager indeed, and who has intermittently battled with
what Churchill called “the black dog”, I felt
the immediate pang of sympathy most fellow-sufferers feel.
Isn’t it bad enough to have acne and A-levels without
the angst as well?
Prince Harry is rich and privileged
beyond the wildest dreams of most – but also bereaved and the product,
like too many children, of a broken home. You might choose
to think that his following in his mother’s footsteps
as a high-profile charity worker is just a public relations
attempt at polishing up a somewhat tarnished adolescence,
but I happen to think it genuine. Earlier last week, the
series That’ll Teach ‘Em in which a group of
cynical, resentful, academically unsuccessful fifteen-year
old were taught at a recreated 1960s secondary modern school.
Stripped of their mobile phones and 21st century pseudo-adulthood,
forced to call teacher’s sir and dress in unattractive
uniforms, they not only had to sit much more demanding
GCSE’s in Maths and English but learn practical skills.
The girls learnt to type, bake and sew, while the boys
learnt to milk a goat, bricklay and make a tea-tray.
The transformation in these teenagers
was absolutely amazing. Not only did they get slimmer,
fitter and much more attractive
as human beings, they also cheered up and blossomed into
radiant self-confidence. Boys who had been truanting and
priding themselves on being cheeky and “hard” turned
out to be simply brilliant at wood-work. Their astonishment
and pride at gaining Grade 1 in GCSE was mirrored by the
girl who, depressed as an academic failure, plugged away
at typing and got a Grade 2. In tears of joy, she said
that whatever anybody said, she knew now she was good at
something – just like the two girls who turned out
to be wonderful cooks. You felt quite certain that you
were witnessing a life-changing experience which only the
stupidest girl chose to turn her back on.
I’m all for academic rigour and an academic elite,
but it’s been obvious for years that successive Governments’ obsession
with academic results is a disaster for those who are not
stupid but simply not wired up to do GCSE Maths and English,
let alone go to one of the ridiculous universities that
are supposed to make all young people employable – assuming
they can even afford a degree. I suspect that many of those
who have added to the numbers of depressed teenagers would
find themselves infinitely happier leaving school at 14
and having a good old-fashioned apprenticeship – if
these still existed – by which they could start earning
a living and some self-respect. The real enemy of happiness
isn’t just the pressure of sitting exams that many
are completely unsuited to taking, it’s the idea
that there is no alternative route into adulthood. Forced
in on themselves, it’s no wonder that so many teenagers,
despite the material privileges provided by parents, become
sunk in apathy and self-pity.
They can’t be wholly blamed for this – after
all, who is there telling them that there is a world elsewhere
in which they will find purpose and happiness? Not schools,
driven by league-tables, or parents, cowed by the prospect
of perennially unemployable offspring. You can’t
make camp fires and dance round them, as the kids in That’ll
Teach ‘Em did, because that’s what little children,
whose world they despise, like doing. You can’t do
sport unless you’re either at a private school or
attending one of the decreasing state schools not to have
sold off its playing fields. Clubbing is expensive, and
so crowded you’d have better exercise in a sauna.
The old kind of clubs, like the Scouts and Guides are terminally
uncool. No wonder the only alternative looks like Prozac,
or the binges on drink, drugs and under-age sex for which
our youth are internationally infamous.
Only 5% of the mental health budget
is targeted at under-16s, which (to anyone who remembers
how absolutely rotten being
14 can feel) seems amazing. Yet the solution to this kind
of problem shouldn’t always lie with Government budgets
and targets, but in ourselves as parents and children.
When I was planning, on a daily basis, how to kill myself
as a teenager, I was rescued by a quiet, wise man called
David Butcher who taught wood-work. Being encouraged to
do something practical instead of the academic work at
which I shone made an incalculable difference to my moods.
As soon as you can see something that was just a lump of
wood become solid and useful as a bowl or a box, your own
wispy sense of identity and sanity suddenly gets a great
jolt of life-giving realism. All kinds of unhappy teenagers,
including the actor Dan Day-Lewis, benefited from those
lessons – significantly, he was one of the only teachers
at my horrible progressive school to be called “Mr.” Butcher,
rather than by his Christian name – as they did from
his William Morris Socialism that persuaded many of us
to get off our privileged bottoms and do charitable work.
The worst thing about depression is
that it makes you completely apathetic, like the victims
of the Spectres
in Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials, or the Dementors
in Harry Potter. The very thing that offers your only chance
of getting better – doing something – is the
thing that above all seems absolutely impossible. When
you’re having a bad time, you become enraged at being
told to snap out of it, and thinking about the less fortunate
is as much help as eating your vegetables while thinking
of the starving in India. It’s paradoxical that teenagers,
who are pumped full of hormones telling them to dance,
mate and have fun are often the ones to suffer most from
this horrible feeling. Yet the moment you compare yourself
with a real, live baby raped and infected with HIV and
lying in your arms, it does become impossible to feel truly,
madly, deeply sorry for yourself again. Prince Harry is
an extreme version of the way forward for kids who, left
to drift at home with a gigantic sense of failure, sink
into drunken loutishness unless redirected outward. The
world is bigger and sadder than you are, and the moment
that you realise it is the moment you start to become a
grown-up.
Perhaps, though, the rest of the world
is becoming like North London. An enchantingly witty
novel by Kate Saunders,
Bachelor Boys, is published by Arrow next month. Its premise,
that young men are all beautiful but useless, lounging
around as unemployed actors, park-keepers and bouncers
while the young women pursue hugely successful careers,
has already struck a chord with Anthony Minghella who has
bought it for film. Saunders’s novel picks up the
kind of conversation you hear all the time among chattering
class mothers, which goes along the lines of “So
Horatia is head of ICI is she? Of course. And Tarquin has
a job as a life-guard at the Lido? How marvellous, well
done him.” Of course, not every young man is as lucky
as the two feckless Bachelor Boys, whose dying mother persuades
a determined young woman with a relentless work ethic to
turbo-charge them into pulling their fingers out. But then
few of us have the kind of people Prince Harry had pushing
him round Lesotho either – only the example he has
set.
|